228 East 36th Street #1B, NEW YORK, NY 10016 · 1B
Murray Hill, Manhattan · 1 BR · $2,950/mo · active as of 9/27/2026
This 1910 building has 6 open HPD violations, including 4 Class C violations—the most serious category, indicating conditions the city considers immediately hazardous to health or safety. These violations apply somewhere in the 20-unit building, not necessarily in unit 1B, so at your viewing ask the broker which units are affected and request documentation that repairs are scheduled or complete. The asking rent of $2,950 is 4% above the borough median of $2,850 for comparable units, though this is based on 16 comparables so the estimate is reasonably reliable. Note this is not a no-fee listing, so factor broker costs into your budget. The listing indicates pets are allowed with a $300 one-time fee. The building has no elevator, which matters less for a first-floor unit, and the past 12 months show zero heat complaints, 311 noise complaints, rodent complaints, or bedbug reports—a quiet track record for a 20-unit building. The photo analysis flagged wide-angle distortion and over-brightening in some interior shots, particularly the living room images, which may make rooms appear larger or brighter than they are. Confirm actual room dimensions and natural light levels in person.
Photos
We looked at 8 of 12 photos (we check up to 8, and skip any that won't load).
Unit photos (0-3) show interior staging and editing. Living room (0-1) exhibit wide-angle distortion and enhanced styling; living room 1 is over-brightened with no natural windows. Bedroom (2) and bathroom (3) appear more authentic with natural window light and minimal staging. Exterior/neighborhood photos (4-7) document the building and surrounding NYC area with natural daylight. Caution: wide-angle lens use may…
Wide-angle lens applied; single large window with bright natural light; furniture and styling appear edited/enhanced
No visible windows; bright overhead lighting; wide-angle distortion; furniture and decor staging apparent
Single large window with natural light entering; cleaner, less styled presentation
Single small window near top; clean, well-lit bathroom; standard documentation style
Classic NYC pre-war brownstone/apartment building facade; natural daylight
Third Avenue storefront/neighborhood shot; natural daylight
Urban plaza with outdoor seating and dining area; natural daylight
Commercial storefront with large street-level windows; natural daylight
We look at the listing's photos where they are published and never store them. These are visual signals, not measurements.
Building
- Built
- 1910
- Floors
- 5
- Units
- 20
- Elevator
- no
- Open HPD violations
- 6 on record
- Class C (immediately hazardous) open
- 4 on record
- Heat and hot water complaints, 12 months
- None on record
- Noise complaints (311), 12 months
- None on record
- Rodent complaints (311), 12 months
- None on record
- Bedbug infested units, last filing
- None on record
Source: NYC Open Data (HPD violations and complaints, 311, bedbug filings, PLUTO), asked Sep 26, 11:36 PM New York time. These are records for the whole building, not this unit, and they lag by days to weeks. Ask the landlord about anything open, which unit it is in and whether it has been fixed.
Who runs it
- Managing agent (HPD registration)
- RANDY GLICK GPG MANAGEMENT
- Listing contact
- Sarah Kalafos, City Wide Apartments Inc
Unit
- Elevator
- no
- Laundry
- not said
- Pets
- allowed
- Available
- 2026-09-17
Price
- Asking
- $2,950
- Broker fee
- mentioned. Under the FARE Act the landlord's broker cannot charge you
- Similar listings we saw (same size, same borough, last 60 days, 16)
- median $2,850, middle half $2,600 to $3,000
- This listing vs that median
- +4%
- Comps advertising a concession
- 6% of 16, so don't count on one