172 W 109th St APT 2E, New York, NY 10025 · 2E
Morningside Heights, Manhattan · 2 BR · $4,200/mo · active as of 9/27/2026
This check is not complete. City building records didn't come back when we asked, so this check is incomplete. That is not the same as a clean record.
The summary from before our checks changed
This apartment is priced 24% below the Manhattan median for comparable units at $4,200/month, which is a significant discount worth understanding, ask the broker directly why the rent is set lower than market and whether there are any lease conditions or trade-offs involved. The listing lacks critical building information including year built, number of units, HPD violation history, and recent complaint data for heat, noise, rodents, or bedbugs, so you should request the building's HPD registration number and look up its violation history on the NYC HPD Online portal before committing. The unit won't be available until September 2026, which is unusually far out, so confirm whether the current lease situation is straightforward and whether that date is firm. Laundry and pet policies are unlisted, and there's no square footage provided, these are worth clarifying in writing. At your viewing, check water pressure, radiator condition, and window seals since building age and maintenance history are unknown.
Go by the rows below. Where a record says not retrieved, we don't know.
Photos
We couldn't check the 9 photos on this listing. Look at them yourself for wide angle stretching and blown out windows.
We look at the listing's photos where they are published and never store them. These are visual signals, not measurements.
Building
Year built, floors and units were not retrieved.
- Open HPD violations
- Not retrieved
- Class C (immediately hazardous) open
- Not retrieved
- Heat and hot water complaints, 12 months
- Not retrieved
- Noise complaints (311), 12 months
- Not retrieved
- Rodent complaints (311), 12 months
- Not retrieved
- Bedbug infested units, last filing
- Not retrieved
Source: NYC Open Data (HPD violations and complaints, 311, bedbug filings, PLUTO). These are records for the whole building, not this unit, and they lag by days to weeks. Ask the landlord about anything open, which unit it is in and whether it has been fixed.
Who runs it
- Listing contact
- Amga Realty, Amga Realty
Unit
- Laundry
- unknown
- Pets
- unknown
- Available
- 2026-09-15
Price
- Asking
- $4,200
- Broker fee
- not stated
- Similar listings we saw (same size, same borough, last 60 days, 183)
- median $5,495, middle half $4,795 to $6,295
- This listing vs that median
- -24%
- Comps advertising a concession
- 4% of 183, so don't count on one